Many people have heard of Terrelle Pryor but can you name any valedictorian coming into Ohio State or who is the top student nationally? Somehow, we have heard of this football player and not the best student coming to Ohio State? Why do you think that is? Right now you can go to a site and see every football player coming in but there is no site that lists each student coming. It is called marketing. Scouting companies help college football by making the fanatic of a school familiar with freshmen who have not taken 1 college class when games start in the fall. Why market? It creates excitement and an atmosphere that people want to be a part. And so the fans know who is on the field which make them hold onto their wallets a little looser. Marketing= selling student athletes (How many non-athletes are sold like athletes?)
Who is considered the best trumpet player coming out of high school? Who is considered the best debator coming out of high school?
Who is considered the best football player coming out of high school? That is easy. Terrelle Pryor, I watched a special last night on him on FSN. I checked the history channel but no high school students are scheduled to be profiled.
Athletes are different. They make the university money. They get paid, right now. Do you think Troy Smith makes the same mistake if he and Maurice Clarrett were being paid a stipend?
Eh? I asked someone else to read that and they said just about the same thing: where in the hell did he pull that from? Sorry...lacks any grain of common sense. But anyway...
Where the hell would you get I would want college sports eliminated? You have been drinking, I am sure. Never a hint of suggestion on that. It is not illegal for a college student to have money during the season. They can work jobs, if they so choose. They can get money from the parents. They can make money in the summer and have money to spend while in season.
Colleges themselves are a business. Not just college athletics. Colleges want to MAKE money. That is how they operate and expand and continue to attact students. Once again, if these kids want to make money right out of high school, GO PRO IN CANADA OR EUROPE! If they don't want to play for the attention brought to them by playing for Ohio State or Michigan or Notre Dame, they do not have to. THey have othe roptions. They are free to get paid there.
And your whole speil about scholarships doesn't make sense. The English is too messed up to follow and be sure I am following exactly what you are saying. Are you saying that if athletics go away, so to scholarships for non-athletic students? Or are you saying that there are now scholarships available to more non-athletic students? Doesn't make enough sense right now to dispatch that, as well.
And Scout and Rivals, who are the main sites you are talking about...for the most part, people have to send in or upload their own information. So if someone doesn't want Scout or Rivals "making money off them," they do not have to create a profile. However, if they want to be recruited, it sure helps. Just their choice: get yourself into the recruiting circle by yourself or don't bother.
And let's look at John Deere mowers. The Ohio State athletic department is the mower. The athletes are the parts of the mower that people recognize, such as the engine and tires, of whom ppl know the manufacturer. However, does anyone know the name of the company that makes the screws or bolts or valve stem covers? Nope. But that doesn't make them any less an important part of the whole machine that is a John Deere mower. If there were no students at OSU other than athletes, Ohio State wouldn't survive as a University. Just like a John Deere mower wouldn't survive out in your yard. Use a car for the analogy as well. Just because the finished product is what people are most familiar with doesn't mean that the tiny parts going into the whole don't matter.
And I was the best debater coming out of high school. Haven't you figured that out yet?
And yes, I do think Smith does make the same mistake. Just because he has problems with following the rules when he isn't getting paid doesn't mean he won't have problems following the rules when he DOES get paid. Does a millionaire drug dealer say he's got enough money from his day job as diesel mechanic and decide to stop accepting drug money? Hell no, he wants the drug money too!!!
In the end, it is still pretty clear: they shouldn't get paid.