68 replies to this topic

[The Cheese]

just gonna throw this out there all the kids that joined the PG soccer team started out playing football, they couldnt take the conditioning or the work and dedication football takes so they took the easier road and played soccer last year and honestly i think its good because a football team doesnt need people that weakly minded, you gotta be mentaly tough to play football and obviously people who cant make it in football turn to socer...

That has nothing to do with it i can guarantee you that there is twice as much running involved in soccer than football lol and i bet if i played football i could make it through the conditioning part just fine- trust me if some of the football players on our team can make it through conditioning i'm pretty sure I can too. haha have you ever thought about the fact that maybe they just like the sport of soccer more? it has absolutely nothing to do with being mentally strong- if our school cut the soccer program i would probly play football.

[T-Money]

So what you are saying is that you are intimidated by soccer. Soccer comes in and the kids wanna play which takes away from your sport that you wanna see kids play. Therefore you are threatened by i tand do not like it. you want football to remain the great sport at your school but kids are taking an interest in soccer. and previous posters are exactly right. Soccer is more of a mans game than football. Football you wear all that padding and have all that protection where in soccer you have virtually none and people run into each other and knock each other down just as much. not to mention if you are goalie you slide in after a ball with ppl kickign at you and have ball blasted at your face. AND soccer is a full 40 minutes, 10 minute break then anothe full 40 minutes...no stopping. and you are not in one position...a defender can end up playing up front awhile, a forward playing midfield and a midfielder defender...anyone has to pla yany position....and how many people use their feet every day in a skillful way other than walking??? not many...now how many ppl use their hands everyday to do skillful stuff...everybody does....having to use your feet instead of your hands takes a lot of skill....where as all football is, unless you are throwing or catching the ball, is running into somebody else with not a lot of actual talent involved. not saying beign smart isnt involved with blocking and such. soccer you have to be smart and talented to play....football you dont need to be nearly as talented or smart...ive played both so i know. didnt play football in high school but still....soccer is much more difficult...its a great game

whoa whoa whoa... hold up! I don't care what sport you like or don't like! Personally i am not a soccer fan... but the above highlighted comments need some further discussion. First of all the contact in football compared to the contact in soccer is TOTALLY different. Im not saying there is no contact in soccer, but most of the time when there is hard contact the referee blows the whistle and stops play, because contact is not an acceptable part of the game. Contact in football is what defines the game! It is encouraged and anticipated... the coaches, referees, and spectators come to watch this contact! This contact is much more violent and frequent, which is why the players wear pads. Those pads do not eliminate the pain that you feel, trust me! They only spread the contact out... the only people who can take that kind of punishment are in UFC or rugby. So do not say that soccer is more of a mans game than football because if you are describing that in terms of physical toughness you most certainly have to be tougher to play football!! As far as the running goes, yes you may need to do more endurance training in soccer than football but i promise you if you were to switch a soccer player to football with a football player who is of the same relative size and athleticism the soccer player would have much more trouble! All those pads, pants and helmet would be extremely difficult to handle for someone used to wearing a lightweight shirt, shorts, no helmet, and MUCH LESS contact. On the other hand the football player would happy to trade more running with all of that!!! Your comments about talent and smarts are unbelievable!!! You have no idea what it is like to memorize thiry+ plays, and blocking schemes, then adjust those schemes (on the fly-as you see it) to varying defenses!

I agree with you that it is petty to come on here and bash soccer and the players, but before you go saying that football is just "running into somebody else with not a lot of actual talent" you should do some research on the techniques, and skills used in football.

[The Cheese]

just gonna throw this out there all the kids that joined the PG soccer team started out playing football, they couldnt take the conditioning or the work and dedication football takes so they took the easier road and played soccer last year and honestly i think its good because a football team doesnt need people that weakly minded, you gotta be mentaly tough to play football and obviously people who cant make it in football turn to socer...

ha what are you a broken record?? here i'll say it again the kids that play soccer simply like the sport more. If soccer was the majority sport in our school would you say that the people who play football are weak minded? Why don't you go over to schools like kalida or ottoville or like any of the other pcl schools and ask them if soccer is for the weak minded?

oh yea the kids that played football in junior high and quit were the ones that never played football in their lives and just wanted to try it out cuz everyone else was doing it so don't give me that crap

Edited by The Cheese, 07 July 2009 - 12:01 PM.

[SoccerManiac]

This is a topic that has created controversy from many ppl as seen here:

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qi...20173501AAzwUNW

and here.......http://ababysit81.sulekha.com/blog/post/2006/08/soccer-vs-football-or-should-it-be-apples-vs-oranges.htm

and here..........http://www.trap17.com/index.php/Football-American-Football_t38930.html


I guess the point I am trying to make that this is not the first time this topic will be brought up or will it be the last. Both sides understandably defend there sports whether soccer or football because they love it and therefor believe that there sport is better than the other. Both sports need tremendous talent, dedication, and teamwork. The sports have unique characteristics that make them different from the other and require different types of skills, players and tactics. NOBODY can say which sport is better because they are so different....they both are special and are awesome in the eyes of their loyal fans which is really what only matters.

[slice slice baby]

This is a topic that has created controversy from many ppl as seen here:

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qi...20173501AAzwUNW

and here.......http://ababysit81.sulekha.com/blog/post/2006/08/soccer-vs-football-or-should-it-be-apples-vs-oranges.htm

and here..........http://www.trap17.com/index.php/Football-American-Football_t38930.html


I guess the point I am trying to make that this is not the first time this topic will be brought up or will it be the last. Both sides understandably defend there sports whether soccer or football because they love it and therefor believe that there sport is better than the other. Both sports need tremendous talent, dedication, and teamwork. The sports have unique characteristics that make them different from the other and require different types of skills, players and tactics. NOBODY can say which sport is better because they are so different....they both are special and are awesome in the eyes of their loyal fans which is really what only matters.

Great posting, maniac!!

I myself, particularly like fb over soccer, but would NEVER try to diminish the talents of the athletes of soccer (or any other sport)..... Each have their own special talent, & as long as ppl are doing what they love as participants & observers, watching what they want, who cares!!??!!??!! There's room for everyone & if it's not your cup of tea, move on!

Also, before anyone says, "soccer is stealing away the fb players", if the players wanted to be playing fb instead, they would....I don't care what size school you have....It's nice that the schools that have soccer give the kids an option---different strokes for different folks!......It's their choice of what to participate in..... Just thank God they're in something & applying themselves & not running around getting in trouble!

All athlete's willing to put in the time & commitment that participating in ANY sport requires, should be commended---no matter the sport! Hats off to ALL of them!

[shot_stopper2010]

im sorry guys but if you are older than 12 and still playing soccer and you arnt going to go pro then there is something wrong

why do u think soccer is the most popular sport in the world!?? i dont see football in the olimpics or in anyohter countries for that matter except once every nfl season so u soccer haters need to get a life

[slice slice baby]

I get a kick out of soccer!

Its actually a kick in the grass!

You slay me, gummy!

[baller93]

you dont even have to be athletic to play football, you just have to be big and take up space.... also, in soccer, you play for a straight 40 minutes (45 in MLS) then there's a 10 minute half-time, then another 40 min. in football, you run a play that last about 5 seconds, stop and huddle up and do it again!!! and you get a break after each quarter....

[SoccerManiac]

you dont even have to be athletic to play football, you just have to be big and take up space.... also, in soccer, you play for a straight 40 minutes (45 in MLS) then there's a 10 minute half-time, then another 40 min. in football, you run a play that last about 5 seconds, stop and huddle up and do it again!!! and you get a break after each quarter....

As you can see by my name that I love soccer ,but I also love football and sports in general. In football you have to be very athletic.....especially insanely strong

[airjordan]

soccer could be the worst sport to play. its for all those BIG BABYS that dont wanna man up and play football like all the real men do. there isnt even no point to it either its just an overall worthless thing to play. be men play football

[The Cheese]

soccer could be the worst sport to play. its for all those BIG BABYS that dont wanna man up and play football like all the real men do. there isnt even no point to it either its just an overall worthless thing to play. be men play football

i would love to see you or any other football player play soccer i can guarantee that you can't handle it. there's 5 times as much running in soccer than football you wouldn't last 10 minutes in a game without getting tired.- most kids that play soccer run a whole 80 minutes NONSTOP running with no timeouts or breaks in between to set up plays. now thats something you can't handle.

grow up kid and think before you talk

[airjordan]

dude i did think your the one who doesnt think worth **** take a freaking soccer player and put him on the football field. they wouldnt last cause they cry about getting hit. and one more time FOOTBALL RULES

[THE-KOOL-AID-MAN]

dude i did think your the one who doesnt think worth **** take a freaking soccer player and put him on the football field. they wouldnt last cause they cry about getting hit. and one more time FOOTBALL RULES

you do know that some schools dont have football and if they did most of those kids would play

[The Cheese]

dude i did think your the one who doesnt think worth **** take a freaking soccer player and put him on the football field. they wouldnt last cause they cry about getting hit. and one more time FOOTBALL RULES

Bring it on dude throw me on the football field I'll take all of you on! Lol how hard could it possibly be? I mean, i only gotta run for 5 seconds at a time, and if i'm gettin hit by pansies like you then hell playin football is like a walk in the park! haha

OHH and one more time GROW UP KID! If you don't like soccer then why are you commenting on the soccer threads? That just shows the immaturity of you. GROW UP GET A LIFE

[airjordan]

ha ha yeah right my football team doesnt have any panzies on it. there real men. now i just hate soccer and this thread says who cares and i dont give a crap about and im going to state my opinion. and by the way if a soccer player did play football they would only be a freaking kicker cause they wont be able to do anything else in life

[baller93]

the only reason that most people hate soccer is becuz they cant play it, if you want to be a real man PLAY SOCCER!!!!

[The Cheese]

ha ha yeah right my football team doesnt have any panzies on it. there real men. now i just hate soccer and this thread says who cares and i dont give a crap about and im going to state my opinion. and by the way if a soccer player did play football they would only be a freaking kicker cause they wont be able to do anything else in life

ha wrong again your football team has at least one Pansy on it... And that's you! Everyone else on your team is cool tho cuz they don't act like their 5 years old!

And I don't know what soccer team your talkin about, but if anyone on my team played football the majority of them would play either line or skill positions. Lol and every single one of them would start over you. haha Even the girls on our team are tougher than you!

[nwohiosportsfan]

there isnt even no point to it

Ok first of all air jordan learn some grammar if you're going to bash a sport try not to sound like some uneducated redneck, and second of all grow up, if soccer is so bad why are you wasting five minutes of your life to post on the forum.

[Rocketman]

I see where this thread is goin' nowhere fast...........kool-aid is already taking a break, who's next?.......RM