28 replies to this topic

[FrOnT RoW JOE]

do I want history more for I team I hate, or Manning, a player I hate??

[Dr. Pirate]

The Pats get caught stealing early in the season, Belichek gets fined a half mill and loses their first round draft pick. then his team goes undefeated into the Super Bowl, which they will most likely win, and become champions. Then the draft comes and they get a top ten draft pick from the 49ers. Talk about the rich getting richer. As for this game though, I detest coach Belichek and his arrogance. I hope the Giants will find a way to win but I am not sure that that will be possible so I am gonna say the Patriots will win, Brady will get another MVP and become immortalized by the media and Belichek made a saint.

[knightmare07]

Alright.....Brady v. Manning

Brady- through 8 seasons
Games-112
Attempts- 3642
Completions- 2294
TD- 197
Int- 86
Yards- 26370
NFL MVP- 1
Pro Bowl- 5

Manning- through 8 seasons
Games- 128
Attempts- 4333
Completions- 2769
TD- 244
Int- 130
Yards- 33189
NFL MVP- 2
Pro Bowl- 6

All right there are the stats that matter... Go ahead and say that Brady has only played in 7 seasons, thats fine.... Manning has played on a team that went 3-13 in his rookie year... If Super Rings make a good quarterback, then the NFL is overrated. NBA titles dont make a point guard good, world series titles dont make a pitcher any better,The greatest Nascar driver of all time won the Daytona 500 once, David Beckham has never won a World Cup, winning an oscar hardly makes you a better director (go ask george lucas), so.... when you look at it, does winning a Super Bowl really matter? Well, yes it does but, look at some hall of famers in the NFL: Dan Marino v. Joe Namath, are you honeslty going to sit there and tell me that Marino was worse than namath or roethlisberger because he doesn't have a ring? Are you going to tell me that Elway was better than Kelly because he has 2 rings, while Kelly made it four times and never won? It takes a good team to win a Super Bowl, not just Manning or Brady. Fine, the Panthers and the Rams had better offenses than the Bears but what about defense? I hardly think that nathan Vasher and Brian Urlacher are bad players. Brady is a good QB but he has also had better teams around him, and don't try to say that he hasn't. WR are better, he has a better, line, better set of core line backers. Peyton Manning could be playing for the Patriots and have three super bowl rings as well...and anybody who says otherwise is a moron.

[Dr. Hibbert]

Dislike both Mannings...and their daddy for that matter. The media loves the brothers Manning almost as much as they do Brett Favre. Eli has been playing out if hi sbutt as of late, I believe the Pats will find a way to make him look like a high school QB. Being a Michigan fan, how can I not want the Patriots to win.

[knightmare07]

Dislike both Mannings...and their daddy for that matter. The media loves the brothers Manning almost as much as they do Brett Favre. Eli has been playing out if hi sbutt as of late, I believe the Pats will find a way to make him look like a high school QB. Being a Michigan fan, how can I not want the Patriots to win.

Mike vrabel, Buckeye, Lawrence Maroney, Golden Gopher, Kyle Brady, Nittany Lion, Rosevelt Colvin, Broilermaker, Matt Light, Broilermaker, that do it for you?

If not how bout this? AMANI TOOMER, THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN, also the Giants have no former Buckeyes, and only one former Spartan

Edited by knightmare07, 23 January 2008 - 08:36 PM.

[tigerball13]

Yeah, but the MVP will also be from UM.

[knightmare07]

So Amani?

[Dr. Hibbert]

How does what do for me KM? The former Big Ten players on the Pats roster? Thats cool too I guess. I have just always been a Big Tom Brady fan.

Pierre Woods, former Wolverine linebacker is on the roster of New England as well as one time Wolverine QB Matt Gutierrez, so that makes 2 1/2 Michigan Men on the Patriots roster.

Amani Toomer...like Amani very much but he also has a Manning on his team so........


Go Patriots!

[knightmare07]

I am rooting for the Pats in this one too....The PATS may very well be my second favorite team but the fact sstill remains that the PATS have BRADY who has a better supporting cast than any other NFL player right now...go ahead and try to argue it, the fact reamins that if this team wasnt in the Super Bowl, would be a joke, and right now there is a big difference for them in an 18-1 season and one that ends with a gooseegg in the loss column.

I have more faith in Brady than Manning in this game, will take Bill before Caughlin, and Welker/Moss before Toomer...will take the New England D before any other NFL D...so with that PATRIOTS 25 GIANTS 16